It was not the rivet but a crack.
Today I dismantled the pedal to have a look at the component side and also inside the pot.
First observation: the faulty pot is a different brand/make from all the others though at first sight it looks stock.
Measurements:

After cleaning the path that leads up to the carbon track the pot reads now open OL.
A strong light and magnifying glass reveals the tiniest hairline crack in the path leading to the carbon track.
By cleaning it I must have removed the 20k dirt that was in the crack. (waiting for Iainpunk here)
The red line in the image below shows where it was. (not the actual pot wafer btw)
I bridged the gap with conductive glue. (in blue on the image)
It's sunday, so I had to make my own. (mixture of glue and magnetised 0000 steelwool dust)

It worked. Pot now reads 9.5k and it goes to 0:

Glued: (grey substance, track at right lug)
