Check your battery, try using a different Jfet (a different 2n5457 I mean), then upload a picture, because the only other thing I can think of is a Jfet with extremely high/low values that might be throwing you off... e.g. a very low Idss (1 mA rather than 3-5 mA) might be affecting your output, for instance, or a much lower Vp than you're used to. Maybe double-check the values of your input and output caps, too...