Charge Pump vs. the correct DC Supply...pros/cons?

Started by skiraly017, March 08, 2007, 01:34:11 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

skiraly017

If I understand what a charge pump does correctly, it allows you to use a 9v power supply in a pedal that requires more than 9v to operate. PLEASE correct me if I'm wrong. So if that's the case, then why not just buy a 12/15/18v power supply if that's what the pedal needs? Are there benefits to a charge pump over the proper power supply and vice versa? Thanks for the help.
"Why do things that happen to stupid people keep happening to me?" - Homer Simpson

PaulC

#1
In one offs there's no benifit to the charge pumps imho.  They can't source a lot of current, and when the voltages drop down (weak battery) they can wig out.  but if you were going into production they have a place because a lot of the pwr supplies people have for their boards might not have the voltages you want.  If you designed a pedal for 18vdc it might not work as well being run on the standard 9 volt supplies.  The pumps let you have the pedals running on what you wanted.  You could go the two battery route also.   some production units do that.

The biggest reason to me is if you want to just plop the pedal on the floor without having to have it plugged into a supply.

there is a nice thing about using pumps to make negative voltages though.  Sometimes you don't want +18.  You might want +9/-9.  Pumps are nice for that with standard power supplies.

what I wish is that the "norm" was for 12VAC supplies.  that would open up a whole new world if all the supplies on the market had that.

Later, PaulC
Heritage amps/Tim & timmy pedals
I like ham, and jam, and spam alot

Pushtone

I'm planning to put a charge pump in a FS&H-A1 build
just so I can power it on the same 9v daisy chain as my other pedals.

The benefit would be not having to add another power supply to the board.

I guess thats more like adapting a bi-polar powered effect to fit into a 9v world.
It's time to buy a gun. That's what I've been thinking.
Maybe I can afford one, if I do a little less drinking. - Fred Eaglesmith

TheBigMan

Yeah, the benefit for me is being able to daisy chain positive ground, bipolar or 18V pedals off the same PSU as "standard" 9V effects.  I've got an Ibanez FL-301 powered this way and it's a lot more convenient than using 2 batteries and then having to remember to unplug the pedal so they don't discharge, or having to use a second PSU.

Ucho

Can I use a charge pump giving +9/-9 (like the one on GGG) inside a pos gnd pedal, taking the -9 out of it and connectig that pedal with others neg gnd pedals without problem?

R.G.

Yes.

In fact, I would recommend that ALL positive ground pedals ought to be powered this way if the current they need is low enough. It ought to be part of the circuit board.
R.G.

In response to the questions in the forum - PCB Layout for Musical Effects is available from The Book Patch. Search "PCB Layout" and it ought to appear.

Ucho

Thanks RG.

So, in this way i can power all my pos and neg ground pedals just with one power supply, avoiding buying (or building) an other one.

analogmike

charge pump adds too much noise for me usually, rather use the correct supply if possible.
DIY has unpleasant realities, such as that an operating soldering iron has two ends differing markedly in the degree of comfort with which they can be grasped. - J. Smith

mike  ~^v^~ aNaLoG.MaN ~^v^~   vintage guitar effects

http://www.analogman.com

Ucho

Quote from: analogmike on March 09, 2007, 02:15:44 PM
charge pump adds too much noise for me usually, rather use the correct supply if possible.

Thanks for the info.
An other problem i'm reading about is the voltage drop...

Maybe I'll try using a charge pump and see... by the way, if I'll use two or more pos ground pedals I'll build a bipolar power supply.